Please call us at 812-449-7718 to place an order.
Be Happy Pie Company makes each pie from scratch using the finest ingredients. Our cases are full of sweet treats daily in a variety of flavors, but we do not make every flavor everyday. If placing a specific order, please allow 24-48 hours.
Our Sweet Menu...
Whole Pies - $20 for 10 inch and $5 for 5 inch Our flaky whole 10-inch and 5-inch pies available in the following flavors... Signature 'Be Happy' Cherry Loaded Chocolate Pecan Apple Streusel Loaded Pecan Awesome Apple Peanut Butter (Only available in 10 inch and 5 inch) Banana Cream Pumpkin Blackberry Crumb Pumpkin Streusel Blueberry Streusel Raisin Cherry Crumb Raspberry Cream Chess Razzle-Dazzle Bumbleberry Chocolate Chess Sweet Potato Chocolate Cream Seasonal flavors include Gooseberry, Blue-Goose, Strawberry, Rhubarb, Peach, Cranberry Pear Coconut Cream Meringue is an extra charge Custard (Plain or with fruit) Icebox Lemon Key Lime Lemon Crumb Pie Bites - $15 for 6 or $30 for 12 Our flaky 3-inch crust cups available in any of the flavors listed above
Pie Poppers - $10 for 12 Our flaky 1-inch crust cups available in any of the flavors listed above
Scrappies - $3 per 3 oz. bag A bag of our delicious pie crust scraps dusted in blend of cinnamon and sugar and baked to perfection.
Scones- $3 or $15 for 6 Blueberry Lemon, Cranberry Orange, Cherry Lime, Hummingbird, Maple Pecan, Chocolate Chip, Pumpkin Spice
'Grandma Good' Cookies- $1 or $10 for 12 Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Crinkle, Couch Potato, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Ranger, Snickerdoodle
Cookie Pies- $3 or $15 for 6 Our Famous Oatmeal Cream Pies and Monster Cookie Pies
Kuchens- $3 or $15 for 6 Three inch German coffee cake available in traditional Brown Sugar Cinnamon, Cherry
Sweet Rolls- $3 or $15 for 6 Soft yeast roll with cinnamon and sugar topped with a velvety buttercream icing
Petite Cheesecakes- $4 Creamy vanilla cheesecake on a buttery shortbread crust available in Cherry, Chocolate Chip, Plain, Raspberry Swirl, and Turtle
Cream Puffs- $3 or $15 for 6 A golden pastry dome filled with a silky blend of vanilla and whipped creams dusted with powdered sugar
Coffee Cake- $3 A deliciously moist and tender cake with a ribbon of cinnamon through the middle topped with a crumbly streusel dusted with powdered sugar
Murphy Bites- $0.50 A crunchy, satisfying dog biscuit made with rolled oats, pumpkin, peanut butter, and eggs
Our Savory Menu...
Chicken Pot Pie- $30 Family Size and $5 for Single Serve Available on Wednesdays only. Best to order by Monday before noon as they sell out quickly. These are take and bake. White meat chicken, red potatoes, peas, carrots, celery, onions in a rich, creamy sauce
BHPC Shepherd's Pie- $30 Family Size and $5 for Single Serve Available for special order; please allow at least 48 hours. These are take and bake. Ground beef with peas, carrots, and onions in a hearty, delicious gravy covered in mashed potatoes
Quiche- $30 Available to order any day, but please allow 48 hours. Roasted Vegetable with Feta Create Your Own with Sausage, Ham, Bacon, Mushrooms, Peppers, Broccoli, Onions, Sundried Tomatoes, Spinach, Cheddar, and Swiss
T-Shirts - $15 Tank Tops - $20 Hats - $20 Long Sleeve Shirts - $22 Aprons - $35